| Print this page | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Issue #47/2026
19 November 2026
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Subscribe now to make the most of this legal bulletin and have full access to judgments and other documents. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
New This Week
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
CASE SPOTLIGHTS
EXTRA EXCEL (M) SDN BHD v. QUEK PECK KEOW & OTHER APPEALS [2026] 10 CLJ 1 (i) A court is justified in bypassing the Kompetenz-kompetenz doctrine, under s. 10(1) of the Arbitration Act 2005, to directly determine the existence or operability of an arbitration agreement where: (a) the relief sought is final rather than a mere procedural stay; (b) the issue involves the pure construction of a written instrument based on undisputed documents and chronology; (c) the subject clause or a materially identical one was already conclusively ruled void or inoperative between the same parties; and (d) a party uses arbitration to relitigate a jurisdictional question it previously lost. (ii) A party holding a unilateral right to amend a standard-form contract cannot retrospectively apply a post-dispute amendment to compel arbitration over a dispute that has already crystallised and is subject to active court litigation. (iii) An arbitration clause drafted solely by one party that restricts who may initiate arbitration will be strictly construed against the drafter, ie, contra proferentem. ARBITRATION: Agreement - Existence and operability - Kompetenz-kompetenz doctrine - Whether court or arbitral tribunal should determine validity of arbitration agreement - Whether there existed circumstances justifying court in making final determination - Whether application for final declaratory and injunctive relief - Whether party attempting to re-litigate jurisdictional issue previously decided - Whether s. 10(1) of Arbitration Act 2005 applicable ARBITRATION: Agreement - Construction - Unilateral amendment by drafter - Agreement provided unilateral right to amend reserved by company - Amendment to arbitration clause made post-crystallisation of dispute and pending appeal - Whether amended clause could apply retrospectively to compel distributor to arbitrate - Whether contra proferentem applied - Whether company entitled to initiate arbitration against distributor CIVIL PROCEDURE: Stay of proceedings - Application for stay pending arbitration - Second stay application relying on textually amended clause - Subsequent application following dismissal of earlier stay application - Whether second application barred by res judicata or issue estoppel - Whether prior decision rendered amended clause inoperative against crystallised dispute JUDICIAL QUOTES“In the recent Federal Court's decision in Amir Hariri Abd Hadi v. PP [2025] 7 CLJ 353, the apex court struck down the legitimacy of s. 9(5) of the Peaceful Assembly Act 2012 (PAA 2012) for the reason that it was not proportionate to the legitimate legislative aim - the right to freedom to peaceful assembly.” “In a similar vein, if DBKL’s consent is required in s. 10(c) of the PAA 2012, it will be inconsistent with the intention of the Act. To insist on DBKL’s consent under s. 10(c) of the PAA 2012 will be not proportionate to the legitimate legislative aim. If such interpretation is to be adopted and applied by this court, it is to permit a stumbling block to seep through the backdoor subverting the right to freedom of assembly vis-à-vis consent is required from a local council to use a public place for a peaceful assembly, without which, the police authority can "reject" the peaceful assembly. Flowing from the foregoing analysis and findings, this court answers the main question in the negative. The consent of DBKL is not a prerequisite for the purposes of s. 9(1) of the PAA 2012. Furthermore, the definition of an "occupier" under s. 10(c) and 11 of the PAA 2012 cannot be stretched to encompass a Local Authority, such as DBKL, whose powers are confined to purely regulatory and custodial functions over a public place.” - Per Choo Kah Sing JCA in Badan Peguam Malaysia & Ors v. Noor Dellhan Yahaya (Police Officer-In-Charge Of Dang Wangi Police District) & Ors [2026] 10 CLJ 665 LATEST CASESLegal Network Series
CLJ 2026 Volume 9 (Part 6) An international organisation does not enjoy absolute immunity in domestic employment disputes, as the statutory protection under para. 1 of the First Schedule to the International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1992 ('IOPIA') is strictly functional. Under s. 11(5) of the IOPIA, statutory immunity is structurally bounded by the underlying international agreement, which in this case explicitly granted the organisation the capacity to employ staff and defend itself in legal proceedings. Consequently, protection is restricted to acts that are strictly necessary for fulfilling institutional objectives; routine administrative actions, such as dismissing an employee for misconduct, fall outside this protected matrix as they do not compromise the organisation's operational independence. Furthermore, by executing an employment contract containing an exclusive choice-of-law and jurisdiction clause in favour of Malaysian courts, an international organisation voluntarily relinquishes immunity and cannot subsequently resile from its agreement. While statutory immunity enjoys a presumption of constitutionality over general constitutional rights unless explicitly impugned, it cannot be expanded beyond its functional and contractual boundaries to evade local industrial jurisdiction. LABOUR LAW | COURTS | CONTRACT | CONSTITUTIONAL LAW
LABOUR LAW: Employment - Dismissal - Unjust dismissal - International organisation - Former employee filed representation for dismissal without just cause and excuse - Claim referred to Industrial Court - Application by international organisation to strike out claim based on jurisdictional immunity - Whether international organisation entitled to absolute immunity from suit or legal process regarding internal human resource management - Industrial Relations Act 1967, s. 33C - International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1992, s. 11(5), First Schedule, para. 1 - Alliance for Financial Inclusion (Privileges and Immunities) Regulations 2016, reg. 5 COURTS: Industrial Court - Jurisdictional immunity - Act of dismissal - Application of functional immunity principle - Termination of employee for alleged misconduct - Whether disciplinary action and dismissal constituted acts in furtherance of organisation's core objectives - Whether adjudication of unlawful dismissal claim by Industrial Court compromised independence or operational policies of international organisation - Whether act of dismissal fell within unprotected administrative matrix - Whether international organisation protected by immunity - Industrial Relations Act 1967, s. 33C - International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1992, s. 11(5), First Schedule, para. 1 - Alliance for Financial Inclusion (Privileges and Immunities) Regulations 2016, reg. 5 CONTRACT: Employment contract - Terms of contract - Submission to jurisdiction - Clause 10.1 of employment contract explicitly providing relationship governed by Malaysian laws and subject to exclusive jurisdiction of Malaysian courts - Interplay with s. 11(5) of the International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1992 and host country agreement - International organisation relinquished immunity and agreed without qualification to subject itself to court's jurisdiction - Relinquishment of immunity in employment matters - Whether international organisation could resile from agreement - Industrial Relations Act 1967, s. 33C - International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1992, s. 11(5), First Schedule, para. 1 - Alliance for Financial Inclusion (Privileges and Immunities) Regulations 2016, reg. 5 CONSTITUTIONAL LAW: Fundamental liberties - Right to life and livelihood - Federal Constitution, art. 5(1) - Deprivation of right to livelihood must be in accordance with law - 'Law' includes valid Acts of Parliament - Statute conferring immunity - International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1992 - Presumption of constitutionality of Acts of Parliament - Whether right to livelihood ipso facto takes precedence over explicit statutory immunity Supang Lian JCA
(i) Apabila wujud dua versi fakta yang bertentangan dan pihak pendakwaan mengemukakan pertuduhan berdasarkan niat bersama dengan seorang tertuduh lain yang gagal dikesan, kegagalan pihak pendakwaan untuk menyangkal kenyataan atau pengakuan saksi/tertuduh bersama tersebut mewujudkan kelompangan material dalam kes pendakwaan. Manfaat keraguan hendaklah diberikan kepada tertuduh sekiranya versi pembelaan munasabah dan tidak disangkal; (ii) Sebelum apa-apa anggapan pengedaran bawah s. 37(da) Akta Dadah Berbahaya 1952 boleh terpakai, mahkamah wajib membuat dapatan afirmatif melampaui keraguan munasabah bahawa tertuduh mempunyai milikan fizikal, kawalan, dan pengetahuan terhadap dadah tersebut. PROSEDUR JENAYAH | UNDANG-UNDANG JENAYAH
PROSEDUR JENAYAH: Rayuan - Rayuan terhadap sabitan dan hukuman - Tertuduh didapati bersalah, disabitkan atas pertuduhan mengedar dadah dan dijatuhkan hukuman mati - Dua versi bertentangan tentang penemuan dadah - Kenyataan/pengakuan tertuduh bersama yang melarikan diri tidak disangkal pendakwaan - Keterangan saksi penting tidak dikemukakan - Sama ada wujud kelompangan dalam kes pendakwaan - Sama ada wujud keraguan munasabah - Sama ada sabitan dan hukuman selamat - Akta Dadah Berbahaya 1952, s. 39B(1)(a) UNDANG-UNDANG JENAYAH: Kesalahan - Pengedaran dadah - Anggapan pengedaran - Elemen milikan - Kewajipan mahkamah membuat dapatan afirmatif tentang milikan fizikal, kawalan dan pengetahuan melampaui keraguan munasabah sebelum anggapan pengedaran terpakai - Sama ada hakim bicara terkhilaf - Sama ada tertuduh berjaya menimbulkan keraguan munasabah atas kes pendakwaan - Sama ada sabitan dan hukuman selamat - Akta Dadah Berbahaya 1952, s. 37(da)
Azman Abdullah HMR
Where a complex commercial transaction is governed by multiple concurrent security agreements executed simultaneously between transacting parties, the court must adopt a holistic methodology, interpreting the instruments harmoniously as a single composite transaction rather than evaluating a single provision of one document in isolation. The scope and enforceability of an absolute third-party deed of assignment over project proceeds are inherently limited by the underlying commercial objective of the transaction and the actual performance of the borrower. Consequently, upon the borrower's cessation of work and subsequent repudiation of the contract, the secured financier's right of collection does not extend absolutely to the entirety of future contract proceeds, but is strictly restricted to the portion of proceeds contractually attributable to the work actually completed by the borrower prior to the repudiation. BANKING | CONTRACT
BANKING: Facilities - Financing facilities - Security documents - Deed of assignment ('DOA') - Third-party assignment of project proceeds - Main contractor executed third-party assignment in favour of subcontractor's bank - Subcontractor subsequently ceased work and repudiated contract - Bank continued to deduct monies from main contractor's escrow account for subsequent progress claims - Interpretation of security documents - Whether High Court Judge erred in interpreting single clause of DOA in isolation - Whether security documents executed simultaneously must be read together as single composite transaction - Intention of parties - Scope and limit of bank's entitlement to security - Whether assignment absolute over entire contract proceeds or restricted to proceeds attributable to borrower's completed work CONTRACT: Agreements - Assignment agreement - Third party deed of assignment - Security documents governed commercial transaction - Execution of third-party deed of assignment alongside other security instruments - Whether documents executed simultaneously formed part of same transaction and must be considered together - Whether inconsistency between clauses arose - Whether assignment absolute over entire contract proceeds or restricted to portion attributable to completed work - Commercial purpose of transaction - Impact of contractual interpretation on public interest in infrastructure projects
Mohd Firuz Jaffril JCA
(i) An application for an order for sale under s. 265(3)(b) of the National Land Code is strictly governed by the 12-year statutory limitation period under ss. 21(1) and 6(3) of the Limitation Act 1953, which runs from the date of the chargor's default. This substantive bar cannot be evaded by characterising a belated court application as a procedural continuation of earlier proceedings, as a procedural mechanism cannot resurrect an extinguished proprietary right; (ii) To reset the limitation clock under ss. 26 to 28 of the Limitation Act 1953, any acknowledgment or part-payment must be strictly proven and made by an authorised representative before the statutory period expires. An unverified, post-expiry payment made by a party lacking lawful authority over an estate fails to bind the estate by virtue of the proviso to s. 28(5) of the Limitation Act 1953. LAND LAW | LIMITATION
LAND LAW: Charge - Order for sale - Application under s. 265(3)(b) of National Land Code - Continuation of earlier proceedings - Whether procedural continuity exempted application from operation of Limitation Act 1953 - Whether procedural mechanism could resurrect extinguished substantive right - Failure of chargee to obtain valid and enforceable order for sale within limitation period - Whether chargor entitled to defeat registered interest of chargee - National Land Code, ss. 265(3)(b), 340(4)(b) LIMITATION: Action - Enforcement of - Order for sale of land - Accrual of action upon chargor's default - Inaction by chargee for 19 years following reference by Land Administrator - Whether application for order for sale filed beyond 12-year statutory period - Whether action barred by limitation - Limitation Act 1953, ss. 6(3), 21(1), 26, 27(1), 28(5) LIMITATION: Action - Fresh accrual of - Statutory requirements - Order for sale of land - Appointment of defendant as nominal estate representative under O. 15 r. 6A of Rules of Court 2012 - Alleged historical payments vague, unsubstantiated, and unevidenced - Whether there were payments received after death of chargor - Absence of signed written acknowledgment - Payment credited after expiration of limitation period and filing of originating summons - Failure to prove payment made by or with authority of estate - Whether post-expiration payment binds estate - Whether limitation period revived - Limitation Act 1953, ss. 26, 27(1), 28(5) - Rules of Court 2012, O. 15 r. 6A LIMITATION: Action - Proceedings - Order for sale - Calculated commercial decision by chargee bank to defer enforcement - Death of chargor during period of inaction - Appointment of estate representative - Whether there was deprivation of estate's opportunity to settle debt, challenge quantum, or obtain evidentiary instructions from deceased chargor - Whether there was inordinate and inexcusable delay causing manifest prejudice to estate - Whether inequitable to grant judicial relief - Inherent jurisdiction of court to refuse relief on equitable grounds - Limitation Act 1953, s. 32
Yusrin Faidz Yusoff J
(i) An injured party is entitled to recover medical and rehabilitation expenses incurred for non-conventional or alternative treatments, in this case, acupuncture treatments, if they are reasonable in the circumstances to promote recovery from severe nerve and muscle injuries; (ii) Associated consequential expenses, including specialised overseas medical travel, temporary local accommodation rent, private nursing care, driver hire, and family travel, are recoverable as special damages where they are reasonably necessary due to prolonged immobility and regional displacement for medical treatment. TORT
TORT: Duty of care - Liability - Premises liability - Escalator collapse in commercial building - Claimant's leg trapped in descending escalator causing severe physical and nerve injuries - Duty owed by building management corporation to visitors/licensees - Common law and statutory duties to maintain escalators in safe condition - Extent of liability of building management - Whether building management could disclaim liability by attributing negligence to maintenance contractor - Whether third-party contractor liable to indemnify building management TORT: Damages - Quantum - Assessment - Escalator collapse in commercial building - Claimant's leg trapped in descending escalator - Severe injuries including crush injury, cut sartorius muscle, fracture of femur cortex, post-traumatic stress disorder, and permanent erectile dysfunction - Whether claim proven - Amounts to be awarded TORT: Damages - Special damages - Recoverability - Escalator collapse in commercial building - Claimant's leg trapped in descending escalator - Expenses incurred for alternative treatment - Acupuncture treatment for severe nerve and muscle injuries - Medical travel expenses to overseas specialist hospital - Temporary residential accommodation rental and driver hire during prolonged rehabilitation - Nursing care and future physiotherapy costs - Whether well-justified and recoverable as special damages
Gan Techiong JC
Under the doctrine of specific discovery, the parameters of 'possession, custody or power' extend beyond physical custody to encompass any relevant documents a litigant has a legal right to obtain from third parties, including financial institutions, land registries, corporate entities, or family members. In matrimonial proceedings, a party cannot evade disclosure through bare denials, computerised search failures, or geographical distance when their own declarations - such as assets explicitly enumerated in a last will and testament - directly contradict those claims and evidence a pattern of selective non-disclosure. Because historical tax returns, corporate holdings, bank accounts, and statutory funds are intrinsically relevant to the adjudication on spousal maintenance and the division of matrimonial property, a litigant who maintains absolute ownership, control, or digital access to such records will be judicially compelled to secure and produce them to ensure a fair trial. CIVIL PROCEDURE | FAMILY LAW
CIVIL PROCEDURE: Discovery - Specific discovery - Application for production of documents relating to respondent's assets and income - Asset list allegedly derived from last will and testament - Relevancy and necessity - Test to be applied - Whether petitioner established that documents are or have been in possession, custody, or power of respondent - Rules of Court 2012, O. 24 r. 7, O. 92 r. 4 FAMILY LAW: Divorce - Matrimonial assets - Division - Specific discovery of documents - Notice of application by husband petitioner for disclosure of wife respondent's income tax statements, properties, EPF, insurance policies, bank accounts, share certificates, and other assets - Whether items listed in respondent's last will and testament - Relevance and necessity of documents to support claims on maintenance and asset division - Whether application 'fishing expedition' or oppressive - Whether respondent guilty of selective disclosure - Rules of Court 2012, O. 24 r. 7, O. 92 r. 4
Clive Jublee JC
An offence under s. 3(1) of the Kidnapping Act 1961, notwithstanding the Abolition of Mandatory Death Penalty Act 2023, remains strictly subject to the bail restrictions of s. 388(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code ('CPC') because its revised penalty extends up to 40 years' imprisonment. Consequently, a court has no uninhibited discretion to grant bail unless the accused satisfies the threshold statutory provisos (being a minor, a woman, or sick or infirm) and establishes exceptional and special reasons. In evaluating these grounds, systemic issues like prison overcrowding are irrelevant, and bare assertions of ill health fail without cogent medical evidence. Furthermore, where the accused is a foreign national with expired social visit passes and no local roots, the acute risk of flight operates as an overwhelming public interest factor against release. A lower court's failure to judicially balance these critical statutory metrics constitutes a serious misdirection by way of non-direction, fully justifying High Court intervention under its revisional jurisdiction. CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE: Bail - Non-bailable offence - Charge under s. 3(1) of Kidnapping Act 1961 - Sessions Court granted bail to accused persons who were foreign nationals - Application for revision by Public Prosecutor under s. 323 of Criminal Procedure Code ('CPC') - Whether there were reasonable grounds for believing accused persons guilty of offence within meaning of s. 388(1) of CPC - Effect of amendments introduced by Abolition of Mandatory Death Penalty Act 2023 - Whether there was failure to address amended statutory framework and give due consideration to nature and gravity of offence and severity of punishment - Whether accused persons subject to restriction under s. 388(1) of CPC - Whether public interest factors weighed heavily against granting of bail -Whether there was serious misdirection by way of non-direction warranting intervention - Whether order granting bail ought to be set aside CRIMINAL PROCEDURE: Revision - Application for - Application for revision by Public Prosecutor under s. 323 of Criminal Procedure Code - Sessions Court granted bail to accused persons charged under s. 3(1) of Kidnapping Act 1961 - Whether non-bailable offence - Whether there were reasonable grounds for believing accused persons guilty of offence within meaning of s. 388(1) of CPC - Effect of amendments introduced by Abolition of Mandatory Death Penalty Act 2023 - Whether there was failure to address amended statutory framework and give due consideration to nature and gravity of offence and severity of punishment - Whether public interest factors weighed heavily against granting of bail - Whether there was serious misdirection by way of non-direction warranting intervention - Whether order granting bail ought to be set aside
Kuldeep Kumar Jamna Dass JC
A marriage solemnised outside Malaysia, but registered under s. 31 of the Law Reform (Marriage and Divorce) Act 1976 ('LRA') at a Malaysian High Commission, is a marriage carried upon the Malaysian registers, thereby engaging s. 107(3) of the LRA to permit the registration of a foreign divorce decree. Malaysian courts will recognise a foreign divorce decree granted by a foreign court of competent international jurisdiction where the foreign court's assumption of jurisdiction mirrors Malaysia's statutory jurisdiction or where the parties and the marriage share a real and substantial connection with the foreign jurisdiction, provided no public policy or procedural impediments exist. FAMILY LAW
FAMILY LAW: Divorce - Foreign divorce - Recognition - Marriage solemnised in Singapore and registered under s. 31 of Law Reform (Marriage and Divorce) Act 1976 ('LRA') at Malaysian High Commission - Dissolution of marriage by Family Justice Courts of Republic of Singapore - Petition for declaratory relief seeking recognition of foreign decree of divorce under s. 107(3) of LRA read with O. 15 r. 16 Rules of Court 2012 - Whether s. 107(3) of LRA applicable gateway for registration - Whether there was real and substantial connection test - Whether there was reciprocity of matrimonial jurisdiction under s. 49(1)(b) of LRA - Whether Singapore decree entitled to recognition in Malaysia
Raja Segaran S Krishnan JC
(i) Once a court delivers a final judgment, it is functus officio. A judge cannot substantively rewrite or cure fundamental, contradictory determinations through informal administrative notes or amended judgments; the 'slip rule' applies strictly to minor clerical or typographical corrections, not substantive alterations; (ii) A plaintiff suffering from amnesia is not barred from discharging his or her burden of proof under ss. 101 and 103 of the Evidence Act 1950; the burden can be fully discharged through cross-examination, material admissions, and objective corroborative evidence. CIVIL PROCEDURE | EVIDENCE | ROAD TRAFFIC | DAMAGES
CIVIL PROCEDURE: Judgments and orders - Grounds of judgment - Contradictory findings in grounds of judgment - Erroneous earlier entry on liability apportionment contradicted by subsequent findings in judgment body - Trial judge issued 'amended grounds of judgment' to correct error - Whether court functus officio - Whether 'slip rule' applied - Whether there were fundamental errors in written grounds of judgment - Whether judgment safe - Whether procedurally defective EVIDENCE: Burden of proof - Personal injury claim - Claim arising from road accident - Claimant suffered from retrograde amnesia - Whether claimant discharged burden of proof despite inability to recall facts - Whether reliance could be placed on admissions, physical evidence and cross-examination - Evidence Act 1950, ss. 101 & 103 EVIDENCE: Documentary evidence - Traffic summons - Payment of summons - Road traffic accident - Traffic summons issued and paid for illegal lane change - Admissibility and weight of traffic summons in civil proceedings - Whether payment constituted prima facie admission of fault - Road Traffic Rules 1959, r. 6(2) ROAD TRAFFIC: Liability - Collision - Appeal against decision of Sessions Court - Motorcyclist collided with motorcar near highway exit slip road - Conflict between oral testimonies - Primacy of physical 'silent evidence' - Vehicle damage profile showed detached rear-left bumper and bent right front fork - Whether physical evidence disproved rear-end collision and corroborated lane encroachment DAMAGES: Personal injury - Claim - Assessment of quantum - Motorcyclist collided with motorcar near highway exit slip road - Motorcyclist suffered from multiple severe injuries - Traumatic brain injury, skull fractures, facial fractures and hearing loss - Permanent disability and loss of future earnings - Whether assessment by trial judge constituted 'wholly erroneous estimate' - Whether awards supported by objective medical evidence Shoba Dorai Rajah JC
ARTICLESLNS Article(s)
LEGISLATION HIGHLIGHTSPrincipal Acts
Amending Acts
PU(A)
PU(B)
Legislation Alert Updated
Revoked
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
