| Print this page | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Issue #46/2026
12 November 2026
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Subscribe now to make the most of this legal bulletin and have full access to judgments and other documents. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
New This Week
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
CASE SPOTLIGHTS
ALLIANCE FOR FINANCIAL INCLUSION (AFI) v. NAZIRA NASIR [2026] 9 CLJ 837 An international organisation does not enjoy absolute immunity in domestic employment disputes, as the statutory protection under para. 1 of the First Schedule to the International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1992 ('IOPIA') is strictly functional. Under s. 11(5) of the IOPIA, statutory immunity is structurally bounded by the underlying international agreement, which in this case explicitly granted the organisation the capacity to employ staff and defend itself in legal proceedings. Consequently, protection is restricted to acts that are strictly necessary for fulfilling institutional objectives; routine administrative actions, such as dismissing an employee for misconduct, fall outside this protected matrix as they do not compromise the organisation's operational independence. Furthermore, by executing an employment contract containing an exclusive choice-of-law and jurisdictional clause in favour of Malaysian courts, an international organisation voluntarily relinquishes immunity and cannot subsequently resile from its agreement. While statutory immunity enjoys a presumption of constitutionality over general constitutional rights unless explicitly impugned, it cannot be expanded beyond its functional and contractual boundaries to evade local industrial jurisdiction. LABOUR LAW: Employment - Dismissal - Unjust dismissal - International organisation - Former employee filed representation for dismissal without just cause and excuse - Claim referred to Industrial Court - Application by international organisation to strike out claim based on jurisdictional immunity - Whether international organisation entitled to absolute immunity from suit or legal process regarding internal human resource management - Industrial Relations Act 1967, s. 33C - International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1992, s. 11(5), First Schedule, para. 1 - Alliance for Financial Inclusion (Privileges and Immunities) Regulations 2016, reg. 5 COURTS: Industrial Court - Jurisdictional immunity - Act of dismissal - Application of functional immunity principle - Termination of employee for alleged misconduct - Whether disciplinary action and dismissal constituted acts in furtherance of organisation's core objectives - Whether adjudication of unlawful dismissal claim by Industrial Court compromised independence or operational policies of international organisation - Whether act of dismissal fell within unprotected administrative matrix - Whether international organisation protected by immunity - Industrial Relations Act 1967, s. 33C - International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1992, s. 11(5), First Schedule, para. 1 - Alliance for Financial Inclusion (Privileges and Immunities) Regulations 2016, reg. 5 CONTRACT: Employment contract - Terms of contract - Submission to jurisdiction - Clause 10.1 of employment contract explicitly providing relationship governed by Malaysian laws and subject to exclusive jurisdiction of Malaysian courts - Interplay with s. 11(5) of the International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1992 and host country agreement - International organisation relinquished immunity and agreed without qualification to subject itself to court's jurisdiction - Relinquishment of immunity in employment matters - Whether international organisation could resile from agreement - Industrial Relations Act 1967, s. 33C - International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1992, s. 11(5), First Schedule, para. 1 - Alliance for Financial Inclusion (Privileges and Immunities) Regulations 2016, reg. 5 CONSTITUTIONAL LAW: Fundamental liberties - Right to life and livelihood - Federal Constitution, art. 5(1) - Deprivation of right to livelihood must be in accordance with law - 'Law' includes valid Acts of Parliament - Statute conferring immunity - International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1992 - Presumption of constitutionality of Acts of Parliament - Whether right to livelihood ipso facto takes precedence over explicit statutory immunity APPEAL UPDATES
LATEST CASESLegal Network Series
CLJ 2026 Volume 9 (Part 5) The mere fact that different competent and experienced valuers arrive at different valuation figures, even by a significant margin, is insufficient to establish negligence or a lack of reasonable skill and care, provided the valuation was conducted in accordance with applicable professional standards and with the exercise of the expected degree of skill, care, diligence, and judgment. BANKING
BANKING: Banks and banking business - Facility - Breach by customer - Loan disbursed based on valuation report - Whether overvaluation of property by valuer - Property auctioned at lower price - Whether bank approved facility prior to instruction to valuer - Whether valuer afforded opportunity to be heard at investigation proceedings - Whether valuer exercised degree of skill and care expected of an ordinarily competent professional valuer - Whether financing approval based on bank's own assessment of borrower's capability - Whether action barred by limitation - Whether bank entitled to damages from valuer
Supang Lian JCA
(i) A settlement letter signed by a homebuyer upon delivery of vacant possession, wherein the buyer accepts payment of liquidated ascertained damages (LAD) in 'full and final settlement' and waives all further claims, constitutes a valid and binding accord and satisfaction under s. 64 of the Contracts Act 1950. In the absence of pleaded and proven duress, coercion, or unconscionable conduct, such an agreement extinguishes accrued claims for the balance of LAD, precluding the buyer from later reopening the settlement on the basis of subsequent legal developments or court rulings; (ii) Under Schedule H of the sale and purchase agreement ('SPA'), a cause of action to claim late delivery LAD accrues only when vacant possession of the parcel is delivered or common facilities are completed, not on the date the SPA is executed. (iii) Delivery of vacant possession supported by a partial certificate of completion and compliance (Borang F1) issued under the Uniform Building By-laws 1984 is valid and effective for the purpose of stopping the accrual of LAD, provided that the partial CCC covers the specific residential block containing the purchaser's parcel and certifies it as safe and fit for occupation. The terminal date for calculating LAD cannot be extended to the date of the full CCC (Borang F) if the delay in issuing the full CCC is solely attributable to outstanding work on unrelated and separate commercial components of a mixed development. CONTRACT | LIMITATION
CONTRACT: Agreement - Sale and purchase agreement - Housing accommodation - Delivery of vacant possession supported by partial certificate of completion and compliance ('CCC') (Borang F1) instead of full CCC (Borang F) - Residential blocks physically completed and certified safe and fit for occupation - Delay in full CCC due to unrelated commercial block in mixed development - Whether delivery of vacant possession supported by partial CCC valid and effective - Whether terminal date for calculation of liquidated ascertained damages extended to issuance of full CCC - Uniform Building By-laws 1984, para. 25(2) CONTRACT: Agreement - Settlement letters - Housing accommodation - Execution of settlement letters upon delivery of vacant possession - Purchaser accepted liquidated ascertained damages ('LAD') payment in full and final settlement and waived further claims without protest - Whether settlement letters constituted valid and binding accord and satisfaction - Whether claims for balance of LAD extinguished - Whether purchaser precluded from reopening settled claims following subsequent judicial developments - Contracts Act 1950, s. 64 LIMITATION: Cause of action - Accrual - Housing accommodation - Claim for liquidated damages - Date of accrual - Whether cause of action for late delivery accrued on date of execution of sale and purchase agreements or on date of delivery of vacant possession - Scope and application of Obata-Ambak Holdings Sdn Bhd v. Prema Bonanza Sdn Bhd & Other Appeals - Limitation Act 1953, s. 6(1)
Azizul Azmi Adnan JCA (Civil Appeal No: W-04B(NCVC)(W)-349-10-2025)
(i) Directors who abuse an absolute administrative and financial stranglehold over a company to execute unauthorised inter-company fund transfers commit a flagrant breach of fiduciary duty and a concerted conspiracy to injure; (ii) Corporate entities are not 'related companies' under s. 7 of the Companies Act 2016 ('CA') merely by sharing common directors; hence, transfers between them lack commercial substance and are inherently fraudulent if they bypass the disclosure mandates of s. 218 of the CA and contradict audited financial statements. In such cases, purported ratifying resolutions are deemed a sham; (iii) Equity favours substance over form. A constructive trust is an equitable remedy, not an independent cause of action. Provided the material facts establishing the fraud or unjust enrichment are fully pleaded in the statement of claim and ventilated through evidence at trial, the court has the discretion to grant the proprietary remedy of a constructive trust to prevent a failure of justice. COMPANY LAW | TORT | TRUSTS | DAMAGES
COMPANY LAW: Directors - Fiduciary duties - Breach - Fraudulent misappropriation of company funds - Directors orchestrated unauthorised transfers of funds from company accounts to third-party corporate entities - Whether funds deployed to settle personal share acquisitions and corporate land liabilities - Whether directors breached fiduciary duties owed to company - Whether there was conspiracy to injure - Whether third party corporate entities held appropriated funds and property on constructive trust - Whether directors acted in breach of fiduciary duties to company - Companies Act 2016, ss. 7, 213 & 218 TORT: Conspiracy - Conspiracy to injure - Fraudulent misappropriation of company funds - Directors orchestrated unauthorised transfers of funds from company accounts to third party corporate entities - Whether directors transferred company funds to satisfy external liabilities of separate corporate vehicles - Proximity of timing between notice of demand and tactical resignations and disposal of corporate shares - Whether acts established pre-meditated, unlawful design to cause economic injury and deplete assets of company - Whether directors conspired to injure company - Companies Act 2016, ss. 7, 213 & 218 TRUSTS: Constructive trust - Misappropriated funds - Corporate vehicles receiving and utilising company funds to settle land purchases and share sale agreements - Whether recipient companies possessed imputed corporate knowledge of fraud via common directors - Whether recipient companies held funds and traceably acquired property as constructive trustees for defrauded company - Application of equitable remedy - Companies Act 2016, ss. 7, 213 & 218 DAMAGES: Remedies - Assessment and quantification - Misappropriated corporate assets - Interlocutory declarations of constructive trust and tracing relief - Whether trial judge correctly quantified structural loss derived from fraudulent fund routing Alwi Abdul Wahab JCA (Civil Appeal No: P-02(NCVC)(W)-1792-10-2024)
Even assuming a public officer or the police force owes an actionable private law duty of care to a private individual to execute a statutory duty or court order, a claim in tort for wrongful neglect or nonfeasance must fail if the plaintiff cannot establish, on the balance of probabilities, that proper performance of that duty would have prevented, avoided, or shortened the damage complained of. Establishing mere delay, deficiencies, or evidentiary weaknesses in the performance of a public duty does not displace the plaintiff's burden to prove factual causation; without concrete proof that timely performance would probably have yielded a different outcome, liability in tort and derivative government liability cannot be established. CIVIL PROCEDURE | TORT | ADMINISTRATIVE LAW
CIVIL PROCEDURE: Appeal - Fresh evidence - Admissibility - Application for leave to adduce post-trial evidence - Evidence concerning transactions long after close of pleadings, trial, and main appeal - Whether evidence would have determining or decisive influence on material issues - Rules of the Court of Appeal 1994, r. 7 - Courts of Judicature Act 1964, s. 69(3) TORT: Nonfeasance - Public duty - Claim for damages for wrongful neglect and delay against police force - Failure to execute warrant of committal - Ingredients to be established - Whether malice or bad faith necessary ingredient - Whether causation established - Whether proper performance of statutory duty would have prevented or shortened damage claimed - Whether personal liability against public officer established - Whether derivative liability arose against Government - Police Act 1967, s. 20(3)(f) ADMINISTRATIVE LAW: Mandamus - Mandamus granted solely to command execution of warrant of committal - Federal Court declined to compel execution of recovery order under Child Act 2001 - Effect on auxiliary obligations - Whether non-compliance with unexecuted recovery order constitutes breach of duty regarding warrant of committal Mohamed Zaini Mazlan JCA
(i) Ekoran pindaan melalui Akta Kanak-kanak (Pindaan) 2016, hukuman sebatan bawah s. 91(1)(g) yang dilaksanakan menurut s. 92 Akta Kanak-kanak 2001 telah secara keseluruhan dimansuhkan sebagai salah satu bentuk hukuman; (ii) Hukuman pemenjaraan bagi tempoh tertentu bagi kesalahan yang memperuntukkan hukuman mati bawah s. 302 Kanun Keseksaan adalah tidak sah dan bertentangan dengan undang-undang apabila dijatuhkan terhadap pesalah kanak-kanak. Apabila seorang kanak-kanak disabitkan atas kesalahan yang memperuntukkan hukuman mati, s. 97(1) dan (2) Akta Kanak-kanak 2001 menetapkan bahawa sebagai ganti hukuman mati, perintah yang wajar direkodkan ialah tahanan di penjara selama yang diperkenankan oleh Yang di-Pertuan Agong, Raja atau Yang di-Pertua Negeri, mengikut di mana kesalahan tersebut dilakukan. PROSEDUR JENAYAH
PROSEDUR JENAYAH: Semakan - Semakan hukuman - Pesalah kanak-kanak - Pesalah dituduh membunuh - Mahkamah Tinggi menjatuhkan hukuman penjara 20 tahun dan tujuh kali sebatan bawah s. 91(1)(g) Akta Kanak-kanak 2001 ('AKK') - Sama ada s. 91(1)(g) AKK masih berkuat kuasa semasa hukuman dijatuhkan - Sama ada hukuman penjara 20 tahun selari dengan peruntukan undang-undang - Hukuman sewajarnya yang patut dikenakan terhadap pesalah kanak-kanak yang disabitkan atas kesalahan membabitkan hukuman mati - Kanun Keseksaan, ss. 34 & 302
Azman Abdullah HMR
A judgment creditor who merely enters a private caveat and holds physical possession of a debtor's land title remains an unsecured creditor under s. 5(2) of the Insolvency Act 1967 ('Act'). To achieve secured creditor status, the physical deposit of a title must be perfected through the registration of a lien-holder's caveat under the National Land Code, as a private caveat merely preserves the status quo without creating a proprietary security interest. Consequently, such a creditor is entirely exempt from the disclosure or valuation requirements mandated by s. 5(2) because the unperfected asset remains part of the general estate that vests automatically in the Director General of Insolvency upon bankruptcy under s. 8(1)(b) of the Act. BANKRUPTCY | LAND LAW | WORDS AND PHRASES
BANKRUPTCY: Creditor's petition - Striking out - Application for - Judgment creditor issued bankruptcy notice for balance of judgment debt - Debtor applied to strike out petition on ground that creditor failed to state willingness to give up security - Whether judgment creditor 'secured creditor' - Act of depositing document of title with solicitor and entering private caveat - Whether created security interest - Whether compliance with s. 5(2) of Insolvency Act 1967 mandatory - Rules of Court 2012, O. 18 r. 19 LAND LAW: Lien - Creation of - Friendly loan agreement - Document of title deposited with judgment creditor's solicitors and private caveat entered - Whether private caveat created proprietary or security interest - Status of creditor holding title without statutory lien - Whether unsecured creditor - National Land Code, ss. 322 & 330 WORDS AND PHRASES: 'Secured creditor' - Definition of - Whether creditor holding private caveat and in physical possession of document of title falls within definition of secured creditor - Insolvency Act 1967, ss. 5(2) & 8(1)(b) Ravinthran Paramaguru JCA
In matters concerning the setting aside of a registered foreign judgment under the Reciprocal Enforcement of Judgments Act 1958 ('REJA'), it is well-settled law that the REJA serves as an exhaustive statutory code that completely ousts the court's inherent jurisdiction to introduce non-statutory grounds for relief. Under s. 5(1)(a)(iii) of the REJA, the judgment debtor bears an absolute legal burden to displace objective documentary proof of service, meaning that a bare affidavit denial, devoid of corroborative material, is legally impotent to discharge this onus. Procedurally, an application to set aside a registration order of a foreign judgment that is filed out of time, without an explicit prayer or a compelling justification for an extension of time, is fatally flawed and cannot be rescued by generic appeals to the interests of justice. CIVIL PROCEDURE | STATUTORY INTERPRETATION
CIVIL PROCEDURE: Judgments and orders - Foreign judgment - Registration - Setting aside - Appeal against decision of Judicial Commissioner ('JC') allowing application to set aside registration order - Appellant local government authority in Scotland obtaining default decree against respondent in Court of Session, Scotland - Default decree registered in Malaysia pursuant to Reciprocal Enforcement of Judgments Act 1958 ('REJA') - Application by respondent to set aside registration order on ground of non-service of notice - Whether respondent received notice of Scottish proceedings in sufficient time to enable defense - Statutory test under s. 5(1)(a)(iii) of REJA - Burden of proof - Whether respondent's bare denial of non-receipt sufficient to displace appellant's contemporaneous documentary proof of service - Whether JC misapplied burden of proof CIVIL PROCEDURE: Setting aside - Application for - Time - Delay - Respondent's unexplained delay in filing application to set aside registration order - Failure to provide satisfactory justification - Whether excessive delay ought to militate against grant of relief CIVIL PROCEDURE: Proceedings - Transfer of proceedings - High Court - Judicial Commissioner ('JC') allowed setting aside application but simultaneously ordered transfer of hearing of setting aside application to Special Powers Division of High Court - Whether orders inherently incompatible - Whether JC erred in ordering transfer of proceedings CIVIL PROCEDURE: Jurisdiction - Inherent jurisdiction - Inherent powers of court - Order 92 r. 4 of the Rules of Court 2012 - Judicial Commissioner invoked inherent powers to set aside registration order to prevent injustice - Nature and scope of inherent jurisdiction - Whether conferred unfettered or arbitrary discretion - Whether inherent jurisdiction exists to supplement and not supplant established procedural frameworks - Whether inherent powers could be used to circumvent express statutory provisions STATUTORY INTERPRETATION: Reciprocal Enforcement of Judgments Act 1958 - Section 5(1)(a)(iii) - Setting aside registration of foreign judgment - Requirement that judgment debtor did not receive notice of proceedings in sufficient time to defend - Burden of proof - Whether bare affidavit assertion satisfied requisite burden of proof
Azizul Azmi Adnan JCA
(i) To successfully establish a claim for unpaid or underpaid monies, such as service charges or minimum wage shortfalls, a claimant must adduce sufficient evidence to prove: (a) legal entitlement to the claimed units or points; (b) the precise value of those units during the relevant period; and (c) the specific fact and exact amount of any unlawful deduction, withholding, or shortfall; (ii) A party asserting a claim for specified monetary shortfalls in a civil or labour dispute bears the legal burden of proving, on a balance of probabilities, both liability and quantum - specifically, entitlement, actual value, and shortfalls - regardless of an employer's duty to maintain employment records. LABOUR LAW
LABOUR LAW: Wages - Minimum wage - Service charges - Restructuring of service charge distribution to form part of minimum wage - Employees claimed underpayment of service charges - Claims allowed by Labour Court but set aside by High Court - Whether Labour Court misdirected itself on evidence - Whether burden of proof rested on employees claiming liquidated sums - Whether employees established necessary elements - Whether employer had duty to maintain wage records - Whether conduct and consent of employees established acceptance of restructured wage
Supang Lian JCA
A co-owner who holds a beneficial share alongside a trust interest for co-beneficiaries is not a bare trustee. Consequently, their dual capacity does not bar them from applying for a court-ordered sale, nor does it prevent the court from exercising its statutory jurisdiction to order a sale under s. 59 of the Trustees Act 1949, s. 25(2) of the Courts of Judicature Act 1964 read with item 3 of the Schedule, and O. 31 r. 1 of the Rules of Court 2012. TRUSTS | CIVIL PROCEDURE | LIMITATION
TRUSTS: Trustees - Powers of trustee - Application for order for sale of trust property - Applicant holding 1/3 undivided share beneficially and remaining 2/3 as trustee for siblings - Whether applicant bare trustee - Whether bare trustee characterisation precluded court from ordering sale - Whether necessary and expedient to order sale - Trustees Act 1949, s. 59 - Courts of Judicature Act 1964, s. 25(2) & item 3 of Schedule - Rules of Court 2012, O. 31 r. 1 CIVIL PROCEDURE: Judgments and orders - Order for sale - Application for order for sale of trust property - Applicant holding 1/3 undivided share beneficially and remaining 2/3 as trustee for siblings - Whether court empowered to order sale - Whether necessary and expedient to order sale - Trustees Act 1949, s. 59 - Courts of Judicature Act 1964, s. 25(2) & item 3 of Schedule - Rules of Court 2012, O. 31 r. 1 LIMITATION: Action - Occupation rent - Claim for occupation rent or mesne profits - Co-proprietor in exclusive possession of trust property - Applicable limitation period - Whether statutory six-year limitation period applied to claims for occupation rent - Limitation Act 1953, s. 6 Arziah Mohamed Apandi J
Under the proviso to art. 5(4) of the Federal Constitution, the requirement to produce a detained non-citizen before a Magistrate strictly demands the physical presence of the detainee. Presenting case documents or files to a Magistrate without the actual detainee present is a procedural non-compliance that violates the Constitution, thereby invalidating any continued detention order. TORT | IMMIGRATION | CONSTITUTIONAL LAW
TORT: Unlawful detention - Damages - Claim for - Non-citizen claimant convicted of drink-driving under s. 45A(1) of Road Transport Act 1987 - Claimant detained for 40 days for alleged immigration offence following completion of sentence for non-immigration offence - Whether claimant informed of reason for detention - Whether there was unlawful detention - Whether claimant entitled to damages IMMIGRATION: Detention - Unlawful detention - Non-citizen claimant convicted of drink-driving under s. 45A(1) of Road Transport Act 1987 - Claimant detained for 40 days for alleged immigration offence following completion of sentence for non-immigration offence - Failure of authority to physically produce detainee before Magistrate - Whether physical presence of detainee mandatory - Whether producing documents alone sufficient to comply with constitutional requirement - Whether detention valid - Immigration Act 1959/63, ss. 34 & 35 CONSTITUTIONAL LAW: Fundamental liberties - Rights of arrestee/detainee - Non-citizen claimant convicted of drink-driving under s. 45A(1) of Road Transport Act 1987 - Claimant detained for 40 days for alleged immigration offence following completion of sentence for non-immigration offence - Failure of authority to inform detainee of true legal basis for detention - Denial of access to legal counsel and family - Denial of right to appeal cancellation of pass - Cumulative effect on fundamental rights - Whether detention lawful - Federal Constitution, art. 5(1), (3) & (4) Jamhirah Ali J
ARTICLESLNS Article(s)
LEGISLATION HIGHLIGHTSPrincipal Acts
Amending Acts
PU(A)
PU(B)
Legislation Alert Updated
Revoked
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
